Skip to content Skip to footer

News Posts

Ha’iku Stream Restoration


Introduction

This was a presentation given by Ellen Kraftsow of the Maui Department of Water Supply (MDWS) on August 13, 2025. The presentation was from work done by MDWS as part of their application for modification of Inflow Flow Standard (IFS) that had been previously set by the State Water Commission (CWRM).

Over the last 10 years or so, the Water Commission had reviewed the Interim IFS (IIFS) of about 46 East Maui streams and changed most of them. But all the streams they reviewed were east of Kakipi Stream, which left the streams to the west, which are closest to the most populated part of Haiku, still under the original IIFS. The original IIFS essentially said that whatever was in a stream on June 15, 1988 was the flow amount that must be maintained. But that date was near the height of sugar cane production, which entailed maximum diversion of stream water, leaving minimal, or no, flow in most streams. The effects of stream diversions were more dramatic east of Kakipi because those communities are highly dependent upon surface water and they were deeply affected by diversions so nobody was paying much attention to Haiku streams west of Kakipi.

Fast forward to 2003 and the Consent Decree between the MDWS and a group of Haiku residents who sued over improper planning for drilling new wells in Haiku. Part of the settlement stipulated that the County would look into restoration of Haiku streams as a condition to drilling more wells for public water. The MDWS finally took on the Consent Decree conditions in 2021 and started doing the work. This has resulted in lots of studies of Haiku (and other nearby) aquifers, as well as this study. (See Further Reading, at the end of this post).

The MDWS did a good job of assembling relevant cultural, historical, and hydrological facts in this presentation. It is a must-read for anyone who is interested in Haiku surface water, stream history, and restoring streams. The public has had the opportunity to weigh-in on this issue through community meetings but more opportunities will arise to make your voice heard, so this is a good summary of the larger Haiku streams.

Presentation

Link to the presentation (this will open in another tab). The total # of slides is 69. It is organized around gulches, moving from west to east. For each gulch (or system, as a stream can have several tributaries), various facts and figures are provided.

Quick Reference guide to the presentation:

  • Page 3 The eight streams under consideration
  • Pages 4-8 Very good maps and views of the streams and the ditches they are diverted into
  • Page 20 – Summary of the IFS modification request to CWRM
  • Page 22 – Kailua (this goes to Baldwin Beach, so is not actually a Haiku stream)
  • Page 24 – Maliko
  • Page 30 – Kanemoeala (not on the IFS list, but an interesting stream)
  • Page 33 – Kuiaha
  • Page 37 – Kaupakalua
  • Page 40 – Manawai’iao
  • Page 45 – Uaoa
  • Page 48 – Keali’i
  • Page 51 – Kakipi

Don’t miss these pages:

  • Pages 27 and 28 – historic painting of Maliko gulch and a recent photo of the same spot
  • Page 62 – Letter relating how Maliko was in the old days.

Further Reading and Resources

Brown and Caldwell put together a four-part study of water demand and supply options, for the MDWS. This research product was also a condition of the 2003 Consent Decree. Part 4 also analyzed Haiku stream restoration. These are collectively called the Feasibility Study and they can be accessed here:

East Maui Water Authority June 2025 Recap

Maui community members and water resource experts met June 16-18 to support Maui residents in shaping a sustainable, equitable, and community-led future for East Maui’s watershed. The meetings focused on community-driven solutions for water resource management to ensure a healthy resilient ecosystem, thriving local communities, and water availability for food security.

Meetings in Keʻanae, Haʻikū, and Kula provided an opportunity for in-depth community conversations with residents of the Nāhiku, Keʻanae, Honomanū, and Huelo State of Hawaii License Areas, as well as Upcountry residents and farmers who are allocated 5.75 million gallons of day for agricultural and residential use.

The next series of meetings focused on Project Prioritization and Funding will take place on October 28 and 29, 2025. View Event Details

Keʻanae

Haʻikū

Kula

Day 1 began in Keʻanae with a tour from Keʻanae to Nāhiku in order to ensure that participants understood the hydrology and mechanics of the East Maui Irrigation system and to ground them in the history of its impacts. Attendees of the tour included residents of the lease areas, as well as stakeholders from throughout the island and journalists (Read the news stories from Overstory Hawaii & Maui Now).

The meetings included an update from East Maui Water Authority Director Gina YoungGroup Break-Out Sessions and Reporting Outand Expert Presentations from the Public Finance Initiative. Discussion questions for each break-out session were tailored to the unique history, geography, and needs of each area.

Keʻanae

Keʻanae Full Meeting Replay: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o6gQ0_oixQs 

Haʻikū

Haʻikū Full Meeting Replay: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vawhAiZSNoI

Kula

Kula Full Meeting Replay: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eD1fWpWHHu0


Summary of Themes & Feedback from this June 2025 Series of Community Conversations

While the Keʻanae, Haʻikū, and Kula communities have unique priorities and perspectives, all 3 communities shared core concerns about community empowerment, infrastructure, equity, education, ecosystem health, and a call for transparency/accountability.

And the unique characteristics of each community were also clear:

Keʻanae’s concerns center on generational stewardship amid a commitment to encouraging a return of younger generations and cultural continuity —  in response to the outmigration that resulted from plantation-era water diversion. There is a push for workforce development and solutions to reconnect youth with kupuna to address these concerns, as well as policy reforms that redress historic inequities.

Haʻikū-Huelo’s dialogue reflects a diverse population where both Hawaiian and non-Hawaiian residents share a commitment to cultural and environmental stewardship. The pain of land and water privatization is felt collectively, and even young people—regardless of heritage—voice grief about changes such as drying streams and diminished opportunities for traditional activities, strengthening joint calls for indigenous rights and careful scrutiny of outside actors in water governance.

Kula’s meeting spotlighted deep frustration over long water meter waitlists and fragmented infrastructure, which has resulted in water waste, as well as concerns that new water sources and upgrades are often prioritized for projects outside Upcountry Maui. This sense of inequity is compounded by skepticism toward proposed rate increases, and strong dissatisfaction over the absence of a comprehensive plan and perceived government inaction on Upcountry priorities. 


Presentations & Surveys

Following the community discussions, four experts from the Public Finance Initiative gave presentations describing how to finance the community’s vision, presenting examples of indigenous governance of land and water projects on the continent, providing guidelines for ensuring decisions align with community values, and detailing a case study of a water utility’s approach to address environmental, sustainability, and indigenous issues. 

“Funding Your Aspirations: A Public Finance Primer” by Lourdes German

Presentation Slides: Full PFI Team Presentation Slides (Kula meeting version) – View/Download

Tó éí iiná: A Lens on Indigenous Rights
by Dr. Karletta Chief

View/Download

“Aligning Decisions with Community Values”
by Dr. Katy Hansen

View/Download

“Models of Global Water Systems: Hunter Water”
by Andrew Simmons

View/Download

Survey Results

As part of this conversation series, we sent out surveys to the Haʻikū and Kula Communities. Survey results as of September 2025 are available to review below, feel free to respond to the survey if you haven’t already.